Western Digital vs Seagate: we take a look at the two storage giants

In terms of storage, Western Digital and Seagate are the manufacturers to beat however there’s hardly ever a transparent winner between the 2. They rival one different in practically each phase of the storage market and are consistently itching to outdo the opposite with improvements in ease of use and energy effectivity.

For those who’re seeking to spend money on a transportable onerous drive or an inner SSD to your PC, there is a good likelihood you will be pressured to decide on between the 2. To make that course of slightly extra easy, we have crunched the numbers and brought a take a look at a few of the key variations between the 2 and their merchandise.

Inside Storage

Each Western Digital and Seagate began out making inner onerous drives, so it solely is smart that the competition begins right here. Arduous drives have advanced immensely over the past 20 years: storage capacities have grown exponentially, and pace and energy effectivity have additionally improved.

Totally different segments of the market have emerged (shopper, fanatic/enterprise, AV) to cater to completely different courses of consumer; those that require larger pace versus capability, for instance. In terms of inner storage, it basically comes down as to whether you need area or pace.


Western Digital was one of many first to supply as much as 2 terabytes of area in its inner SATA onerous drives. Now, the corporate presents as much as 6TB for desktops and 2TB for laptops. Nevertheless, Seagate drives are available each cheaper and quicker, although solely marginally – an 8TB Barracuda (Amazon) drive sells for round AU$50 cheaper than Western Digital’s 6TB providing.

Seagate additionally presents a Professional model of the Barracuda with as much as 14TB of storage (Amazon), although not and not using a hefty price ticket. We’d choose Western Digital’s Blue vary (Amazon) for these on a finances, however in the event you can afford one thing higher-end then Seagate’s drives are very tempting.

If you would like higher efficiency from a tough drive, Seagate presents a HDD/SSD hybrid vary, the Firecuda SSHD. The 2TB desktop mannequin (Amazon) consists of 8GB of NAND flash reminiscence as well up and cargo video games quicker.

Trending :   4 best car battery charger and jump starter - What You NEED to Know

Strong State Drives (SSD)

Trending: Best external hard drives of 2022

On the strong state entrance, each firms supply speedy drives designed to entry and write your knowledge as quick as doable. Western Digital and Seagate have been each initially reluctant to speculate into the solid-state drive subject, although they’re now roughly neck-and-neck.

Each firms’ SATA SSDs, Seagate’s Barracuda 510 (Amazon) and Western Digital’s Blue 3D (Amazon), are virtually the identical when it comes to pace, each providing a most of 2TB. Within the newer NVMe vary, the Firecuda 510 is the place Seagate edges out the competitors, although as soon as once more solely marginally; the Western Digital Black 3D NVMe is dearer although not as quick because the Firecuda 510.

In our overview, Jon L. Jacobi got here away equally impressed with Seagate’s FireCuda 520 saying that “The FireCuda 520 is a superb drive, practically as quick as any we’ve seen within the PCIe 3 benchmarks, and has the additional benefit of supporting PCIe 4, which presents a noticeable leap in sustained throughput.”

[Related: Everything you need to know about NVMe]

Winner: Seagate

Seagate is at the moment on prime of the race for bigger inner storage and pace, although not by a lot. Western Digital nonetheless holds its personal within the lower- to mid-range market.

Exterior Storage

Exterior storage is nice for backing up private and company knowledge, in addition to for transporting massive quantities of data from one pc to a different. The higher alternative on this case is a matter of who offers one of the best safety, largest capacities and most suitable option of connectivity.


Western Digital and Seagate each supply a wide range of pocket exterior onerous drives with variations in capability and connectivity. We want the colorful designs of Western Digital’s My Passport vary (Amazon), although Seagate’s Backup Plus Transportable drives (Amazon) aren’t unhealthy trying both. Whereas Seagate might supply 5TB of storage right here as a substitute of Western Digital’s 4TB, the latter is cheaper – it’s a matter of private choice.

Trending: 10 Best External Hard Drives Usb Reviews & Comparison

Trending :   8 Best External Drives for MacBook Pro in 2022

Nevertheless, if pace and safety are what you’re in search of, the WD Passport SSD (Amazon) most capability of 2TB will be encrypted with 256-bit AES utilizing WD’s safety software program. Whereas Seagate’s SATA drives have this functionality, their comparable Quick SSD (Amazon) doesn’t. The latter additionally opts for a USB-C cable as a substitute of a standard USB, which can irk some customers.

In our overview of Seagate’s Quick SSD, we famous that “

at smaller sizes, the Quick SSD is a bit more costly than the competitors. But, in the event you’re seeking to purchase in on the 1TB or 2TB fashions, the distinction between how a lot Seagate’s providing will value you and that of the competitors is genuinely staggering.”

If cables simply aren’t your factor, Western Digital additionally supply wi-fi variations of their Passport vary in as much as 4TB (Amazon), with built-in SD card readers. It is a subject that Seagate is but to enter.


Western Digital wins out on the subject of bigger capacities, providing its My Guide Duo (Amazon) with 20TB of storage in both a RAID 0 or RAID 1 configuration, together with loads of connectivity. Against this, one of the best Seagate can muster is 10TB of storage from the single-drive Backup Plus Hub (Amazon) or Growth Desktop. To the common individual, both firm’s drive could be far more than sufficient storage for images, movies, music and the odd doc backup. For those who’re seeking to do 4K and even 8K video enhancing, or one thing else equally storage-intensive, Western Digital is your finest guess.

One other edge that Western Digital has is their My Cloud (Amazon) line. Plugging immediately into your Wi-Fi router, the drives enable customers to backup their recollections immediately from smartphones and different units utilizing a companion app. Seagate are at the moment and not using a related product because the launch of their Private Cloud again in 2017.

Community-attached storage and residential theatre

NAS units seem considerably of an afterthought for Seagate, although Western Digital appear to have embraced the development.

Western Digital presents the My Cloud Professional (Amazon) and Professional traces in as much as 40TB, and Seagate are at the moment and not using a first-party NAS server altogether because the aforementioned Private Cloud. Plainly they’ve as a substitute opted to only produce NAS-designed drives, with the IronWolf vary (Amazon) in as much as 14TB.

Trending :   The 7 Best Snow Shovels Reviews and Buying Guide

Trending: Best external hard drives in 2022: desktop drives for extra storage and backing up

[Related: Best NAS Hard Drives: Seagate vs Western Digital]

It’s fascinating to notice that within the decade since this text was initially written, each Western Digital and Seagate have stopped producing their particular residence theatre units, which was as soon as a good battle for lounge-room dominance.

WD MyCloud Pro
WD MyCloud Professional

As a substitute, WD’s My Cloud Professional presents built-in assist for Plex Media Server, which organises your library and permits streaming to any enabled machine – smartphones, Chromecast, PlayStation 4 and extra. Whereas Seagate drives will be integrated into NAS servers and utilized in the identical method, they’re and not using a high-capacity server with related capabilities.

Our overview of the Western Digital’s My Cloud Dwelling concluded that “There’s room for enchancment however the My Cloud Dwelling is completely a compelling choice to contemplate. Although the software program powering the expertise does include a number of freckles, it nonetheless manages to supply a level of possession, management and consolidation over your digital footprint that sells itself. It’s not fairly a NAS neither is it fairly a transportable onerous drive, however it’s dead-simple.”

Winner: Western Digital

Western Digital guidelines the coop on the subject of exterior onerous drives, recognising that ease-of-access to digital media and wi-fi connectivity at the moment are extra vital than ever. Nevertheless, whereas Seagate are but to faucet into the wi-fi and cloud-storage market, their choices shouldn’t be ignored.

This text was initially printed on sixth July 2009 by James Hutchinson. It was up to date thirtieth April 2019 by Sarah Lewis after which by Fergus Halliday on January twenty ninth 2021.

Tags storageseagatewestern digital

Have you been searching for the Best 14TB External Hard Drives for your needs? You are at the right place. We recognize that amidst so many choices in the market, it can be perplexing and confusing to make the right pick.

Source: https://www.pcworld.idg.com.au/article/309735/western_digital_vs_seagate_we_take_look_two_storage_giants/

Related Posts